Are marine diatoms favoured by high Si:N ratios?

Competition experiments were performed first with 4, then with 11 species of marine phytoplankton at various ratios of si1icate:nitrate and various light intensities. Diatoms became dominant at Si:N ratios >25:1 while flagellates were the superior competitors at lower ratios. The light supply did not influence the competitive position of diatoms and non-siliceous flagellates in general, while it was important in determining the outcome of competition at the species level. In the 11 species expenments, Stephanopyxis palmenana was the dominant diatom at high light intensities. It shared dominance with Lauderia annulata at medium and low light intensities and high Si.N ratios. Pseudonitzschia pungens was the dominant diatom at low light intensities and relatively low Si:N ratios. The green alga Dunaliella tertiolecta was the dominant flagellate at high light intensities, while at low light intensities the prymnesiophycean Chrysochromulina polylepis and the cryptophyte Rhodomonas sp. were also important

The relationships between resource ratios and phytoplankton composition during the spring period in five North German lakes

Phytoplankton species composition and the availability of potentially limiting resources were investigatcd in five northern German lakes (Suhrer See, Kellersee, Behler See, PluBsee, and Krummsee) during spring 1988. Species composition was related to resource ratios to test Tilman’s resource-ratio hypothesis. The clearest results were obtained for Aulacoseira spp. Both the time-courses within the lakes and the comparison among the lakes suggest a strong tendency of this genus to become dominant at high Si : light ratios. Fragilariaceae occupied the next position on the Si : light gradient. Such conditions permitted them to become important even when Si : P ratios were quite low. With the onset of stratification diatoms were replaced by flagellates

Silicon consumption and population density changes of dominant planktonic diatoms in Lake Constance

(1) Interactions between silicon concentration and diatom growth have been studied in Lake Constance with data on number and volume of cells per unit volume of water and concentration of dissolved reactive silicon. (2) Concentration of dissolved reactive silicon was found to decrease markedly during the spring and summer growth period of diatoms in 1979 and 1980. (3) Amounts of silicon taken up per cell and per unit cell volume have been calculated from the changes in silicon concentration and the increases in population density for several diatom species. The silicon to cell quotient (mg per million cells) varied over a wide range from 0.005 for Stephanodiscus hantzschii to 0.72 for Synedra acus, while that of silicon per unit cell volume (mg mm-3) varied over a narrower range from 0. 10 for Stephanodiscus hantzschii and Fragilaria crotonesis to 0.36 for Synedra acus. (4) A four-compartment model, that allows estimates of the rates of growth and of loss of diatom populations to be calculated, is outlined. (5) Summer succession from Asterionellaformosa to either Fragilaria crotonensis (in 1979) or Stephanodiscus binderanus (in 1980) is explained by interspecific differences in the effects of silicon concentration on growth and death. For Asterionellaformosa, silicon depletion did not stop cell-division but led to the death of most of the population. For Fragilaria crotonensis and Stephanodiscus binderanus cell division stopped but cells did not die and population growth continued after the concentration of dissolved silicon had increased agai

Copepod growth and diatoms: insensitivity of Acartia tonsa to the composition of semi-natural plankton mixtures manipulated by silicon:nitrogen ratios in mesocosms

The feeding selectivity and the growth and reproductive success of the copepod Acartia tonsa have been studied in mesocosms fertilized at different Si:N ratios (0-1.75:1) and, therefore, at different compositions of the phytoplankton communities. Phytoplankton composition showed a strong response to nutrient ratios, with diatoms comprising > 90% at Si:N ratios > 1:1 of total biomass as opposed to < 20% at the lowest ratio. A. tonsa strongly preferred feeding on motile prey (flagellates and ciliates) to feeding on diatoms. Nevertheless, diatoms comprised a substantial part of the diet at the highest Si:N ratios. A. tonsa egg production and the final (after 4 weeks) abundance of adults and copepodites showed no response to Si:N ratios while nauplii production slightly increased with Si:N ratios. It is concluded that the frequently reported deleterious effect of diatoms on copepod reproduction is rather unusual when copepods are confronted with a naturally diverse phytoplankton assemblage instead of clonal cultures in the laboratory

Nutrient competition experiments with periphyton from the Baltic Sea

Nutrient competition experiments were performed with periphytic microalgae from the Kiel Fjord, western Baltic Sea. Diatoms were dominant competitors at high Si:N ratios (under N-limited conditions) and high Si:P ratios (under P-limited conditions). Under low silicate supply, cyanobacteria became dominant at low N:P ratios and chlorophytes at high ones. Changes in light intensity influenced the outcome of competition at the species level but not at the level of higher taxa. The nitrogen source (ammonium or nitrate) had no impact on the outcome of competition

Convergent succession of phytoplankton in microcosms with different inoculum species composition

Different initial mixtures of phyto-and zooplankton from different lakes were grown under identical chemical and physical conditions in medium size (8-and 12–1) laboratory microcosm cultures until convergence of phytoplankton species composition was attained. Five such experiments with four (four experiments) or three (one experiment) microcosm cultures were run. Three experiments were performed with weak stirring which permitted sedimentary elimination of the diatoms. Two experiments were conducted with stronger stirring to prevent sedimentation. In the three ldquosedimentation intensiverdquo experiments, the final phytoplankton community was composed of the filamentous chlorophyte Mougeotia thylespora together with a smaller biomass of nanoplanktic algae. In the two ldquosedimentation freerdquo experiments the final phytoplankton community consisted of pennate diatoms. Both dissolved nutrient concentrations and the chemical composition of biomass suggested strong nutrient limitation of algal growth rates in the final phase of the experiments. The zooplankton communities at the end of the experiments were composed of species that were apparently unable to ingest the large, dominant algae and that presumably fed on the nanoplanktic ldquoundergrowthrdquo and the bacteria. There was a distinct sequence of events in all experiments: first, the large zooplankton species (Daphnia and Copepoda) were replaced by smaller ones (Chydorus, Bosmina, rotifers); second, all cultures within one experiment developed the same nutritional status (limitation by the same nutrient); and third, the taxonomic composition of phytoplankton of the different cultures within one experiment converged. The last took 7–9 weeks, with is about 2–3 times as long as the time needed in a phytoplankton competition experiment to reach the final outcome

Benthic microalgal diversity enhanced by spatial heterogeneity of grazing

This study presents model experiments on the effect of the spatial pattern of herbivory on primary producer diversity. Microalgal biofilms (periphyton) were exposed to different mixtures of two benthic herbivores, the isopod Idothea chelipes and the gastropod Littorina littorea. The herbivores are similar in their feeding selectivity but differ strongly in the spatial pattern of grazing. Idothea did not increase the spatial heterogeneity of algal cell densities beyond the level of ungrazed controls (<1 order of magnitude between local minima and maxima at the 1 mm2 scale). Littorina grazing, in contrast, created a pronounced spatial heterogeneity with maximum:minmum ratios of almost 3 orders of magnitude. When algae were exposed to mixtures of both gazers, the spatial heterogeneity of microalgal cell densities increased with an increasing proportion of Littorina in the herbivore mixture. Algal species richness, diversity and evenness also increased with increasing proportions of Littorina, and was highly significantly correlated with the spatial heterogeneity of cell densities

Comparative nutrient status and competitive interactions of two Antarctic diatoms (Corethron criophilum and Thalassiosira antarctica)

The nutrient status of two common Antarctic diatoms (Corethron criophilum and Thalassiosira cf. antarctica) was analysed by studying the growth response in enrichment bioassays and by estimates of the cell quotas of Si, N and P after size-fractionation of net plankton samples Corethron had higher biomass-specific N-quotas; Si- and P-quotas were quite similar between both species. Corethron was Si-limited in five enrichment experiments and not nutrient limited in five experiments. Thalassiosira was not nutrient limited in six experiments, N-hmited in four experiments and Si-limited in one experiment Droop-kinetics of Si-limited growth of Corethron and of N-hmited growth of Thalassiosira were obtained by combining the growth rates in the bioassays and the cell quotas from the natural populations. The minimal Si-quota of Corethron was 0 041 mol Si/mol C, the saturating cell quota was 0.158 mol Si/mol C respectively The minimal N-quota of Thalassiosira was 0 0223 mol N/mol C, the saturating cell quota was 0.208 mol N/mol C Corethron was N-saturated at cell quotas of >0 106 mol N/mol C; Thalassiosira was Si-saturated at cell quotas of <0 132 mol Si/mol C. As the better competitor for N and the poorer one for Si, Corethron became more important with increasing Si N ratios, while Thalassiosira became more important with decreasing Si:N ratios in the wate

Sedimentation of principal phytoplankton species in Lake Constance

Sedimentation of nine phytoplankton species was studied in Lake Constance with the aid of sedimentation traps exposed at six different depths from 20 to 120 m. The study examines sedimentary fluxes at all depths, temporal variation of sinking velocities into the uppermost trap, annual averages of the sinking velocities at all depths and survival of algae during the sedimentation process. In spite of high intraspecific temporal variability of the sinking velocity there is a clear hierarchy from the pennate and the filamentous centric diatoms sinking the fastest to the Cryptomonads, nearly not at all affected by sedimentary losses. Temporal variability of the sinking velocity within species seems to be related to the ‘physiological state’, the highest velocities always occurring during stationary or decline phases of the population development. An analysis of the role of sedimentary losses in the population dynamics of Asterionella formosa, Fragilaria crotonensis, Stephanodiscus binderaniss, Melosira granulata reveals positive correlations between the sedimentation rate and cell mortality

Silicate and the functional geometry of marine phytoplankton

The impact of nutrient supply ratios on the functional geometry of phytoplankton has been studied by means of competition experiments with phytoplankton communities from the Arabian Sea. Cell length and deviation from spherical shape of dominant competitors increased with Si:N ratios.Surface:volume ratios were minimal at intermediate Si:N ratios. Grazing by the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis did not lead to a qualitative shift in the response of geometric properties to Si:N ratios; however, mean cell lengths increased while surface:volume ratios decreased